March 14, 2024 - CSIQ

Canadian Solar's Quiet Pivot: Is This the End of "Sell It All" Recurrent Energy?

Canadian Solar just reported a strong first quarter, exceeding revenue and margin expectations. Analysts focused on the usual suspects: TOPCon module production, the potential impact of the AD/CVD petition, and the booming energy storage business. But hidden beneath the surface lies a potentially tectonic shift in Canadian Solar's strategy, one that could redefine its future profitability and valuation: the evolution of Recurrent Energy.

Recurrent, Canadian Solar's project development arm, has long followed a "develop and sell" model. They create massive solar and storage projects, secure PPAs, then sell the assets to institutional investors, reaping immediate profits but ceding future cash flows. This strategy, while successful, left Recurrent vulnerable to cyclical swings in project valuations and limited its long-term earnings potential.

However, whispers of change emerged in the Q1 2024 earnings call (Canadian Solar Inc. (NASDAQ:CSIQ) Q1 2024 Earnings Conference Call Transcript). While analysts zeroed in on the imminent BlackRock investment, a deeper dive reveals a more profound shift. Ismael Guerrero, Recurrent Energy's CEO, nonchalantly dropped a bombshell: "We have decided to hold other valuable assets over the long run."

This seemingly innocuous statement signals a potential departure from the "sell it all" strategy. Instead of maximizing immediate gains, Recurrent is strategically choosing to own and operate projects in key markets. This "build and hold" approach, though sacrificing short-term revenue bursts, promises a treasure trove of long-term, stable cash flows.

Ismael's comment about "valuable assets" wasn't just empty rhetoric. He went on to highlight Recurrent's massive 1.5 gigawatts of solar projects under construction, emphasizing their focus on securing long-term PPAs, particularly with data center giants like Amazon.

Consider this: Recurrent already has 700 megawatts of PPAs with cloud service providers and is negotiating hundreds more. These contracts, often exceeding 10 years, offer predictable, long-term revenue streams, a goldmine for a company seeking stable earnings.

This shift aligns perfectly with the global surge in clean energy demand, particularly from data centers. As Ismael noted, "The projections [for data center power demand] they have for the short term are much higher than what we see on any of the reports that are usually distributed on the market."

Recurrent is positioning itself not just as a project developer but as a critical power provider for the data center revolution. This strategic pivot transforms Recurrent from a cyclical project seller to a stable utility-like entity, with guaranteed cash flows and a vastly improved valuation proposition.

Projected Growth of Recurrent Energy's Operating Portfolio

The following chart illustrates a hypothetical growth trajectory for Recurrent Energy's operating portfolio based on information from the Q1 2024 earnings call.

Valuation Implications

Let's crunch some numbers. Assuming a conservative 70% of Recurrent's 4 gigawatt operating portfolio by 2026 is under 10+ year PPAs at an average price of $0.05 per kilowatt-hour, the annual revenue would be $1.4 billion. Using a conservative 5% capitalization rate, common in utility valuations, this translates to a $28 billion valuation for Recurrent's operating portfolio alone.

This dwarfs the $2 billion implied valuation from the BlackRock investment and suggests a massive undervaluation of Recurrent's long-term potential. Add CSI Solar's implied $5.5 billion valuation based on recent transactions in the industry, and Canadian Solar's combined value soars to over $33.5 billion, nearly 30 times its current market cap.

Of course, this is a hypothetical scenario. Recurrent's transition will take time, and many factors can influence future valuations. But the evidence is compelling: Canadian Solar is quietly transitioning Recurrent Energy from a project seller to a long-term asset owner, a move that could unlock enormous shareholder value and propel it into a new era of profitability.

Analysts might be focused on the shiny new toy of energy storage, but the real story might be the quiet revolution happening at Recurrent Energy. This strategic pivot, if executed successfully, could transform Canadian Solar from a cyclical solar manufacturer to a global clean energy powerhouse, leaving those who missed the early signs wondering how they failed to see the sun rising in a new direction.

"Fun Fact: Recurrent Energy's 1.5 gigawatts of solar projects currently under construction are equivalent to the power output of roughly three Hoover Dams! This demonstrates the immense scale of Recurrent's operations and its crucial role in driving the clean energy transition."