The global job market has been anything but predictable in recent years, a rollercoaster of unprecedented highs and stomach-churning lows. This volatility hasn't spared even the most established players in the HR technology sector. Take Recruit Holdings, the Japanese giant behind Indeed.com: despite grappling with declining revenues, they've pulled off a remarkable feat that seems to have slipped past most analysts' radar – a significant and unexpected surge in profitability.

On the surface, Recruit's Q3 2024 earnings call paints a picture of a company navigating turbulent waters. HR Technology, the company's flagship segment, saw a 17.2% year-over-year decline in US dollar-based revenue. The broader picture wasn't much rosier, with full-year consolidated revenue predicted to remain flat and the specter of declining profits looming. Yet, tucked away in the details of their announcement, a different story unfolds.

Recruit Holdings projected a consolidated adjusted EBITDA of ¥585 billion for the fiscal year, fueled by significant margin increases in both Matching & Solutions and HR Technology. This surprising turnaround was attributed to rigorous cost controls implemented throughout the fiscal year, a proactive strategy that has begun to yield impressive results.

While analysts understandably focused on the headline revenue figures, Recruit was busy quietly optimizing its operations, pushing its adjusted EBITDA margin up by 2.5 percentage points to 18.3%. Even more remarkably, HR Technology managed to beat its own margin outlook, clocking in at a robust 33.2%.

This begs the question: how did Recruit Holdings achieve this seemingly contradictory outcome of increased profitability amidst declining revenues? The answer lies in a combination of strategic cost management and an ambitious initiative dubbed "Indeed PLUS."

Indeed PLUS: A Game Changer in the Japanese HR Market

Indeed PLUS, a project two years in the making, represents a bold move to unify Recruit's Japanese HR operations. This platform seamlessly links multiple job boards, streamlining the hiring process and promising greater efficiency for both employers and job seekers. While still in its nascent stages, early feedback from clients points to a positive reception, citing increased job applications and a more streamlined experience.

The impact of Indeed PLUS extends beyond simple efficiency gains. By shifting revenue from HR Solutions to Indeed Japan, Recruit aims to capitalize on the immense potential of the Japanese market, the second largest globally after the US. This shift in revenue recognition – moving from a gross basis to a net basis – might initially appear as a revenue dip, but it masks the underlying strength of the unified platform.

A Prudent Approach to Monetization

Further bolstering its profitability drive, Recruit has made the strategic decision to sunset its Pay-Per-Application (PPA) model in the US. While this model initially held promise, it encountered hurdles in its implementation, particularly with larger clients who found the rapid response requirements cumbersome. This, coupled with employers exploiting the system's loopholes, led to a significant increase in rejections, prompting Recruit to pivot towards a more sustainable model.

While details about the new model remain under wraps, Arai, the Senior Vice President of Corporate Strategy, hinted at a more nuanced approach. The emphasis will be on continuously adding value and refining the existing Pay-Per-Performance (PPSA) model, aiming for gradual improvements in unit price and customer satisfaction rather than drastic overhauls.

This cautious yet strategic approach to monetization speaks volumes about Recruit's long-term vision. They are not chasing short-term revenue spikes at the expense of long-term growth and customer loyalty. Instead, they are laying the foundation for a future where AI-powered matching drives greater efficiency and value for all stakeholders.

Shareholder Returns: A Testament to Confidence

Perhaps the most compelling evidence of Recruit's success lies in their shareholder return strategy. Despite suspending large-scale M&A activities, they announced a share buyback program in December, demonstrating a commitment to capital efficiency and shareholder value. This move, coupled with a history of strong dividend payouts, speaks volumes about the company's confidence in its financial position and future prospects.

Indeed PLUS: Projected Impact

Source:

Adjusted EBITDA Margin Growth: HR Technology vs Matching & Solutions

Source:

It's clear that Recruit Holdings is not just weathering the storm, but using it as an opportunity to reimagine its business model. While declining revenues have captured the headlines, the company has quietly and effectively shifted gears, prioritizing profitability and setting the stage for sustainable growth in a rapidly evolving HR landscape. This under-the-radar transformation might just be the sign of a sleeping giant preparing to wake up – and investors would be wise to pay attention.

"Fun Fact: Recruit Holdings owns Glassdoor, a website where employees and former employees anonymously review companies and their management."