May 11, 2024 - PAYS

The "Black Box" of Pharma: Why PaySign's Pricing Transparency Could Be a Billion Dollar Game Changer

Buried within PaySign's latest earnings call lies a potential seismic shift in the pharmaceutical co-pay assistance landscape. While analysts have understandably focused on the company's impressive growth in patient affordability programs and the windfall from the Change Healthcare cyberattack, a subtle but significant clue suggests PaySign is leveraging a revolutionary strategy: **pricing transparency**. This seemingly mundane detail could be the key to unlocking a billion-dollar opportunity and catapulting PaySign to the forefront of the industry.

The co-pay assistance market, a critical component of pharmaceutical marketing, helps patients afford expensive medications by offsetting their out-of-pocket costs. However, the market has long been shrouded in opacity, with opaque pricing structures and complex arrangements often leaving pharmaceutical companies in the dark about the true cost of their programs. This "black box" approach has allowed established players to dictate terms and extract significant profits, leaving manufacturers with little leverage and even less clarity on program efficiency.

PaySign, a relative newcomer to the space, has astutely recognized this vulnerability and is offering a starkly different proposition: **open, transparent pricing**. CEO Mark Newcomer hinted at this strategy during the call, drawing a parallel with the interchange fee practices of the payments industry. In the past, interchange fees, the charges levied by card networks on merchants for processing transactions, were often shrouded in secrecy, leading to significant cost variations and a lack of clarity for merchants. However, regulatory changes and the emergence of transparent pricing models have empowered merchants and injected much-needed competition into the market.

PaySign appears to be applying a similar playbook to the co-pay assistance market. By offering clear, upfront pricing structures, they're empowering pharmaceutical companies to make informed decisions and compare program costs directly. This transparency, coupled with PaySign's focus on technological innovation and claim processing expertise, is proving to be a potent combination, allowing them to secure numerous high-volume program transitions from established competitors.

The numbers speak for themselves. PaySign's patient affordability revenue surged a staggering 305% year-over-year in Q1 2024, with claim volumes increasing 235%. While the Change Healthcare outage undoubtedly contributed to this growth, the consistent message from both Newcomer and Matt Turner, President of Patient Affordability, points to a deeper, more sustainable trend: **manufacturers are actively seeking alternatives to the traditional "black box" approach**.

This shift towards transparency has the potential to reshape the entire co-pay assistance market. The industry is estimated to be worth north of $500 million, with some projections exceeding $1 billion. As manufacturers become increasingly aware of the cost savings and program optimization opportunities presented by PaySign's transparent model, it's not unreasonable to expect a significant market share shift in their favor.

Consider this: If PaySign captures just 20% of the co-pay assistance market, based on a conservative $500 million market size, they could generate $100 million in annual revenue from this segment alone. This would not only eclipse their current plasma donor compensation business, but also significantly boost their overall profitability and valuation.

Revenue Growth Comparison: Patient Affordability vs. Plasma Donor Compensation

The chart below depicts the revenue growth of PaySign's two primary segments, highlighting the explosive growth in patient affordability.

Here's the crux of the hypothesis: **PaySign's pricing transparency is not just a competitive advantage, it's a potential catalyst for a market-wide disruption**. Much like the emergence of transparent interchange fee models empowered merchants, PaySign's approach is giving power back to pharmaceutical companies, allowing them to demand greater value and accountability from their co-pay assistance providers. This could trigger a cascade effect, forcing other players to adopt transparent pricing models or risk losing significant market share to PaySign.

Of course, this is still an early stage hypothesis. PaySign's success hinges on their ability to continue scaling their operations, winning new programs, and maintaining their technological edge. However, the evidence suggests they're tapping into a powerful market dynamic: **the need for transparency and accountability in the complex world of pharmaceutical co-pay assistance**. If their strategy proves successful, PaySign could not only rewrite the rules of the game, but also redefine the financial landscape for both pharmaceutical companies and patients.

"Fun Fact: The co-pay assistance market emerged as a response to the rising cost of prescription drugs, particularly specialty medications. As drug prices increased, pharmaceutical companies sought ways to help patients afford their treatments, leading to the development of co-pay assistance programs."