While everyone is focusing on the recent acquisition of HSBC Canada and its potential to drive Royal Bank of Canada's (RBC) return on equity (ROE) higher, a silent force has been working behind the scenes, quietly fueling the bank's impressive performance. It's not a flashy tech acquisition or a bold foray into a new market. It's something far more mundane, yet surprisingly potent: Guaranteed Investment Certificates (GICs).

Yes, you read that right. Those seemingly boring, low-risk investment vehicles that your grandparents love have become a hidden engine powering RBC's growth.

The evidence is hiding in plain sight within the earnings transcripts. In Q1 2024, RBC reported a staggering $10 billion increase in GICs quarter-over-quarter. This wasn't just a one-off event. For several quarters, RBC has seen a consistent rotation of client funds into GICs, driven by a combination of excess liquidity and a lack of retail investor confidence in riskier assets like equities and mutual funds. As Dave McKay, RBC’s CEO, aptly pointed out, Canadians are sitting on a massive $350 billion in surplus deposits, a large portion of which is currently parked in GICs.

This "GIC gold rush" presents a unique opportunity for RBC. While the bank acknowledges competitive pressure on GIC spreads, they remain healthy, providing a solid stream of net interest income (NII). This influx of low-cost funding is further bolstered by RBC's market-leading deposit franchise, which continues to attract new clients at a record pace.

Here's Where Things Get Interesting:

The typical narrative around credit cycles suggests that declining interest rates lead to lower provisions for credit losses (PCLs). However, the GIC gold rush creates a potential counter-narrative. As interest rates decline, a portion of these GIC deposits is likely to flow into other savings vehicles, like mutual funds. This creates a liquidity challenge for the bank, potentially requiring them to replace these deposits with more expensive wholesale funding. This could, in turn, exert upward pressure on PCLs, defying the expected downward trajectory.

Hypothetical Scenario:

Let's put some hypothetical numbers to this scenario. Assuming a conservative 25% of the $350 billion in surplus deposits currently held in GICs rotate into other investments as rates decline, that's a whopping $87.5 billion in potential liquidity outflow. Even if RBC manages to replace only half of this outflow with wholesale funding at a higher cost, the impact on PCLs could be significant.

RBC's Proactive Strategy:

While this scenario presents a potential risk, it's important to remember that RBC is not just passively riding the GIC wave. The bank is actively investing in its deposit franchise and exploring new funding avenues like cash management in the U.S. Furthermore, the potential outflow from GICs into investment products presents a significant opportunity for RBC's wealth management businesses to capture a substantial inflow of funds, offsetting some of the NII pressure.

GIC Holdings: A Double-Edged Sword?

The takeaway here is clear: the GIC gold rush is a potent force, one that has been largely overlooked amidst the HSBC acquisition buzz. While this influx of low-cost funding is currently benefiting RBC's ROE, it also presents a potential liquidity challenge as rates decline. The bank's ability to navigate this evolving funding landscape will be a crucial determinant of its future performance. While the HSBC acquisition undoubtedly plays a role in RBC's growth story, the silent power of GICs cannot be ignored.

To illustrate the potential shift in funding as interest rates decline, let's consider a simplified infographic:

Let's examine a hypothetical table showcasing the potential growth and subsequent decline of RBC's GIC holdings as interest rates rise and eventually fall:

"The term "GIC" is primarily used in Canada. In the United States, a similar investment product is known as a "Certificate of Deposit" (CD)."

References: