September 26, 2023 - SMGKF

The Hidden Signal in Smiths Group's Earnings: Is This the End of a Multi-Year Boom?

Smiths Group, the engineering conglomerate with fingers in pies from aerospace to energy, just delivered another record-breaking quarter. Revenue is soaring, profits are fattening, and investors are happy. But hidden within the celebratory rhetoric of its latest earnings call, a subtle but potentially significant shift occurred: a change in the language surrounding inventory.

For years, Smiths has proudly touted its ability to convert over 100% of its operating cash flow. This metric, a testament to their efficient operations, was a key point of differentiation in a world of bloated balance sheets. In the latest earnings call, however, there's a new emphasis on framing inventory build-up not as a temporary anomaly, but as a strategic "investment." Could this be a signal that the end of Smiths' multi-year operational cash flow dominance is in sight?

While acknowledging the impact of strong customer demand and supply chain constraints, CFO Clare Scherrer emphasized the company's "investment in inventory" as a key factor in their lower operating cash conversion this half. Scherrer stated that this investment would "in turn, support medium-term growth," suggesting that the current inventory build-up is not just a temporary reaction to volatile market conditions.

This shift in language becomes even more interesting when we look at the specifics of Smiths' inventory composition. Paul Keel, CEO, explained that the bulk of the inventory increase resides within John Crane (work-in-process) and Smiths Detection (finished goods). While this aligns with the strong order books in both divisions, it also points to a potential inflection point in their cash conversion cycle.

Inventory Breakdown: John Crane vs. Smiths Detection

The question then becomes: is this "investment" a sign of confidence or a harbinger of potential challenges ahead? The answer likely lies in the sustainability of the demand driving this inventory build-up.

John Crane is benefiting from a confluence of factors, from post-COVID recovery to the energy transition wave. However, the traditional energy sector, a key driver of Crane's business, is notoriously cyclical. If demand softens, Crane could be left with an excess of work-in-process inventory, weighing on cash flow.

Smiths Detection, with its reliance on large government contracts, is also susceptible to volatility. Delays in program implementation or changes in government priorities could impact the timing of revenue recognition, impacting cash conversion.

Hypothesis: Inventory-to-Sales Ratio as a Leading Indicator

Here's a simple hypothesis to test: if Smiths' inventory levels (as a percentage of sales) continue to rise in the coming quarters, even as revenue growth moderates towards their medium-term target of 4% to 6%, it would strengthen the argument that the company is entering a new phase where sustaining 100% operating cash flow conversion becomes more challenging.

This chart is a hypothetical representation based on the analysis of Smiths Group's earnings call transcripts and financial data.

This doesn't mean Smiths is in trouble. Far from it. Their underlying businesses remain strong. But it does suggest that investors should pay close attention to their inventory management moving forward. A sustained increase in inventory levels, coupled with softening demand, could signal a shift in the company's historically impressive cash flow dynamics.

"Fun Fact: Did you know that Smiths Group's technology was used in India's historic Chandrayaan-3 mission, helping the country become the fourth nation to successfully land a spacecraft on the moon? They provided components for the lander's fluid handling system, showcasing their expertise in highly specialized engineering solutions."