May 7, 2024 - UBS
Hidden within the dense financial jargon of UBS's Q1 2024 earnings call lies a strategic gamble that could either solidify their dominance in the global wealth management landscape or backfire spectacularly. While most analysts are focused on the immediate impact of the Credit Suisse acquisition and the looming regulatory changes in Switzerland, a deeper analysis reveals a longer-term bet on a slower, more controlled growth trajectory. This strategy, driven by a laser focus on improving returns on risk-weighted assets (RWA), signals a potential shift in UBS's growth philosophy and begs the question: is this a calculated risk or a sign of a bank hesitant to fully embrace its newfound scale?
The key to understanding this bet lies in UBS's projections for net new assets (NNA) in their Global Wealth Management (GWM) division. While the division has exceeded expectations, attracting $27 billion in NNA in Q1, UBS has set a seemingly modest target of around $100 billion per annum through 2025. This comes on the heels of impressive growth, with $77 billion in NNA since the Credit Suisse acquisition closed. Why would a bank, boasting the largest wealth manager in the world with nearly $4 trillion in invested assets, deliberately slow down when they are positioned for a land grab?
UBS executives argue that this restrained approach is a calculated trade-off for long-term value creation. They are acutely aware that the Credit Suisse portfolio inherited a legacy of capital-intensive exposures, underpriced products, and misaligned risk-reward structures. Instead of chasing headline-grabbing NNA numbers, UBS is focusing on a meticulous "balance sheet hygiene" program, carefully repricing or exiting low-returning exposures. They are prepared to sacrifice short-term growth to sanitize the balance sheet and enhance capital efficiency.
"The numbers tell a compelling story. Credit Suisse's revenue-to-RWA ratio stood at a paltry 5% in 2022. Through targeted actions, UBS aims to raise this metric significantly, even if it leads to some asset outflows in the near term. The target of $200 billion in NNA annually by 2028, nearly equivalent to the entire Credit Suisse franchise they acquired, demonstrates the potential upside of this strategy. UBS is effectively betting that a healthier, more efficient balance sheet will attract higher-quality client relationships and ultimately unlock a higher growth trajectory from 2026 onwards."
However, this strategy is not without its risks. UBS is operating in a fiercely competitive global landscape. By deliberately slowing down, they risk ceding market share to more aggressive competitors. The European wealth management market, in particular, is witnessing a wave of consolidation, with rivals like Amundi actively pursuing acquisitions. Furthermore, the ongoing uncertainty around regulatory changes in Switzerland, potentially leading to higher capital requirements, adds another layer of complexity to this bet.
This chart illustrates UBS's projected NNA growth in its GWM division, reflecting the "slow and steady" strategy.
What makes this even more intriguing is that UBS itself acknowledges the potential downside. They have repeatedly emphasized the need for flexibility and optionality in their execution plans. While they remain confident in their ability to achieve their long-term ambitions, they have also hinted at the possibility of adjusting their strategy should market conditions or regulatory requirements necessitate a change of course.
This begs the question: is this slow-growth strategy a genuine commitment or simply a temporary measure to buy time and assess the evolving landscape? Could it be that UBS, despite its bullish rhetoric, is harboring some lingering doubts about its ability to fully digest the Credit Suisse acquisition and navigate the turbulent regulatory waters in Switzerland?
The answer, as is often the case in the high-stakes world of finance, lies somewhere in the grey area between confidence and caution. UBS has a proven track record of prudence and discipline, but they are also a bank with a history of ambition. This $100 billion bet on slow and steady growth is a bold gamble, and only time will tell whether it pays off. One thing is certain, however, the future of global wealth management is being shaped in Zurich, and the outcome of UBS's calculated risk will have ripple effects across the industry.
"Fun Fact: Did you know that UBS has a world-renowned art collection featuring over 30,000 pieces? This collection, often loaned to museums worldwide, is a testament to the bank's long-standing commitment to cultural patronage."